Evaluation of opener design and packing force requirements on no-till seeded canola, wheat, and pea
Peer Reviewed StatusNon-Peer Reviewed
MetadataShow full item record
An understanding of how direct seeding implement opener design and on-row packing pressure influence crop emergence and grain yield would help producers in their selection of appropriate seeding equipment for their farm and soil conditions. A field trial was conducted at three locations in Saskatchewan between 1997 and 1999 to evaluate the effect of direct seeding opener and packer design in combination with on-row packing pressure on the emergence and grain yield of wheat, canola and field pea. The opener-packer combinations included a Bourgault spoon with both a steel "V" and flat rubber packers, a Morris paired-row with both a steel V and flat rubber packer, and a 30 cm sweep with 13 cm spread of seed followed by a 13 cm pneumatic tire. Packing was applied at 0, 74, 124, 174 and 224 lb/wheel. The 0 packing treatment had no wheel following the opener (unpacked). The locations were selected to range in soil texture, and included a loam (Sylvania), silt loam (Watrous) and heavy clay (Indian Head). The differences observed between opener + packer combinations in this study were varied and generally not in excess of approximately 10% for grain yield, and almost always associated with opener design not packer type. Despite the variable results, there was a tendency for higher pea and wheat emergence with the sweep + tire compared with other opener types at the site years that tended to be drier. Also, grain yield tended to be greater for the sweep + tire at the location that tended to be wet in most years and had a heavy-textured soil. Packing pressure responses tended to be associated with different years and varied among the large-seeded crops (pea and wheat) and canola. Generally speaking, 74 lb per press wheel will provide optimal emergence and grain yield across varied environmental conditions, regardless of the opener + packer combination. For example, 5% more pea seedlings emerged with some amount of packing compared with no packing in 1997. Wheat grain yield was 13% greater at three of the location by year combinations, and wheat emergence was 9% greater in 1998, with some amount of packing. Excessive packing pressure (i.e., the two highest vs. lower packing pressures) resulted in 11 less canola seedlings in 1999, a wet year. It would seem that the choice of opener + packer combination will be of agronomic or economic significance across typical environmental conditions that occur across the Canadian prairies. A packing pressure of 74 lb per press wheel will provide optimal emergence and grain yield across varied environmental conditions.
Part OfSoils and Crops Workshop
The following license files are associated with this item: