University of SaskatchewanHARVEST
  • Login
  • Submit Your Research
  • About
    • About HARVEST
    • Guidelines
    • Browse
      • All of HARVEST
      • Communities & Collections
      • By Issue Date
      • Authors
      • Titles
      • Subjects
      • This Collection
      • By Issue Date
      • Authors
      • Titles
      • Subjects
    • My Account
      • Login
      JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.
      View Item 
      • HARVEST
      • Electronic Theses and Dissertations
      • Graduate Theses and Dissertations
      • View Item
      • HARVEST
      • Electronic Theses and Dissertations
      • Graduate Theses and Dissertations
      • View Item

      How do medical students learn professionalism and develop professional identities? An institutional ethnography of the curriculum at one medical school

      Thumbnail
      View/Open
      GAO-DISSERTATION-2021.pdf (10.07Mb)
      Date
      2022-01-27
      Author
      Gao, Yuchen
      ORCID
      https://orcid.org/ 0000-0001-6658-9928
      Type
      Thesis
      Degree Level
      Doctoral
      Metadata
      Show full item record
      Abstract
      Professionalism and professional identity are becoming central topics in educating tomorrow’s physicians. This dissertation is an institutional ethnography of the curriculum on professionalism and professional identity at one medical school. By examining the three types of curricula – the formal curriculum, the informal curriculum, and the hidden curriculum – and highlighting the gaps between them, this study provides a detailed account and an explanation of medical students’ learning experiences with professionalism and professional identity. Utilizing the methodology of IE, I conduct document analysis, participant observation, and in-depth interviews with medical students and faculty to reveal institutional practices, identify social relations, and describe students’ learning experiences. I apply a combination of Giddens’s structuration theory of understanding the complexity of social practice, and Lave and Wenger’s understanding of the context of social practice – community – to analyze the processes and consequences of students’ development of professionalism and professional identity formation in medical education. In pre-clerkship, the medical school’s institutional practices of narrowly defining professionalism and equating the concept to student professionalism and professionalism in professionals is not effective in transformative learning to support students’ development of medical professionalism and professional identity formation. Clerkship is a more significant stage of learning of professionalism and professional identity formation as students’ immersion in the community of medical practice provides not only explicit but also tacit knowledge to master the practice of medicine. Through legitimate peripheral participation in a situated learning environment, students develop a more realistic understanding of medical professionalism and physician roles and develop a specialty-defined professional identity. Many changes have been made to the formal curriculum and, to some extent, the informal curriculum in medical education to support students’ learning of professionalism and development of a professional identity that performs more roles than simply the medical expert. However, the gap between what students are taught in classroom and what they observe and are taught in practice is still significant. Medical students continue to develop and negotiate their professional identities in the context of competing discourses where the other physician roles often lose the battle to the role of medical expert.
      Degree
      Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.)
      Department
      Sociology
      Program
      Sociology
      Supervisor
      Wotherspoon, Terry
      Committee
      Quinlan, Elizabeth; Dickinson, Harley; D'Eon, Marcel; Dell, Colleen
      Copyright Date
      June 2021
      URI
      https://hdl.handle.net/10388/13795
      Subject
      Sociology of medical education
      professionalism
      professional identity
      Collections
      • Graduate Theses and Dissertations
      University of Saskatchewan

      University Library

      © University of Saskatchewan
      Contact Us | Disclaimer | Privacy